Consequences for 4-Year Olds
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/deaa2/deaa29a0f904f09a4be378d2a2274bc86c61419a" alt="Image"
I was reading a parenting blog in which the author used an example of what to do if a child lied about taking the papers and markers off the teachers desk. Her suggested consequence was that she couldn't use the papers and markers for the rest of the day. That is clearly punishment, especially at 4 years old. The consequence to a 4 year old taking paper and markers off the teachers desk is to coach him into putting them back and making a big deal by thanking him for putting them back. Then teaching him how to ask to use them in the future. (Photo courtesy Photo by Jason Sung on Unsplash ) I suggested that she keep in mind that herr focus on CONFRONTING THE LIE and then applying PUNISHMENT RATHER THAN TRUE CONSEQUENCES are very confrontational and could cause a parent or teacher to NOT really get the results they are really looking for... a cooperative and independent child. Instead, the results could create a child who might feel bad, fight more and even lie more. The late philoso...